Custom Software vs SaaS: What Real Estate Teams Really Need in 2025
Date Published
Custom Software vs SaaS: What Real Estate Teams Really Need
You're paying $400/month for a CRM. Another $200 for email marketing. $150 for transaction management. $100 for an IDX website. $80 for e-signature. $50 for showing scheduling.
Total: $980/month ($11,760/year) for a patchwork of tools that barely talk to each other, force you to adapt your workflow to their limitations, and charge more every year.
Meanwhile, you're still exporting CSVs and manually copying data between systems because your "integrated" SaaS stack doesn't actually integrate.
Here's the question nobody asks: What if you built exactly what you need, once, and owned it forever?
In this guide, we'll break down the real costs, benefits, and trade-offs between custom software and SaaS for real estate teams—no vendor bias, no BS, just honest analysis to help you make the right decision for your business.
Table of Contents
- The True Cost of SaaS (It's More Than You Think)
- When SaaS Makes Perfect Sense
- When Custom Software is the Smarter Investment
- The Build vs. Buy Decision Framework
- What Custom Software Actually Costs
- Real-World Case Studies
- Common Myths About Custom Development
- How to Get Custom Software Built (Without Getting Burned)
The True Cost of SaaS (It's More Than You Think)
Most real estate teams dramatically underestimate the total cost of their SaaS stack. Let's do the math:
The Visible Costs
Typical real estate team (5 agents) SaaS expenses:
| Tool | Monthly Cost | Annual Cost | |------|-------------|-------------| | CRM (Follow Up Boss, LionDesk) | $400 | $4,800 | | Email Marketing (Mailchimp, Constant Contact) | $200 | $2,400 | | Transaction Management (Dotloop, SkySlope) | $150 | $1,800 | | IDX Website (AgentFire, Placester) | $150 | $1,800 | | E-Signature (DocuSign) | $80 | $960 | | Showing Software (ShowingTime) | $60 | $720 | | Social Media Scheduler (Hootsuite) | $50 | $600 | | Video Email (BombBomb) | $50 | $600 | | Total | $1,140 | $13,680 |
That's visible cost. Now add the hidden ones:
The Hidden Costs
Data entry and duplicate work:
- CRM doesn't talk to transaction management
- Manually copying contact info between systems
- Re-entering data that should auto-populate
- Estimated cost: 5 hours/week × $50/hour × 52 weeks = $13,000/year
Training and onboarding:
- Learning 8 different tools
- Training new team members on each
- Re-learning after platform updates
- Estimated cost: 20 hours/year × $50/hour = $1,000/year
Workarounds and limitations:
- Tools don't do exactly what you need
- Paying for features you don't use
- Missing features you desperately need
- Opportunity cost: Difficult to quantify, but real
Price increases:
- SaaS prices increase 10-20% annually
- Year 5 cost is often 50%+ higher than Year 1
- 5-year projection: $13,680 → $21,000+/year
Vendor lock-in and switching costs:
- Data export often painful or impossible
- Migrating to new tool costs time and money
- Estimated switching cost: $5,000-10,000 when you finally leave
The Real 5-Year Cost of SaaS
Conservative estimate:
- Subscription fees: $75,000
- Hidden labor costs: $65,000
- Switching costs (if you change): $10,000
- Total: $150,000 over 5 years
And at the end, you own nothing. Stop paying, lose access to everything.
---
When SaaS Makes Perfect Sense
Let's be fair: SaaS isn't inherently bad. For certain situations, it's the smart choice.
Use Case #1: You're a Solo Agent or Very Small Team
Scenario:
- 1-2 agents
- Standard workflow
- Limited technical knowledge
- Tight budget
Why SaaS wins:
- Low upfront cost ($100-300/month)
- No maintenance burden
- Familiar tools with support
- Can start immediately
Recommended approach: Use mainstream SaaS, accept the limitations, focus on selling.
---
Use Case #2: You're Testing a New Business Model
Scenario:
- Just starting out
- Experimenting with different niches
- Unclear about long-term needs
Why SaaS wins:
- Flexibility to pivot
- Test without major investment
- Cancel if it doesn't work
- Learn what you actually need before building
Recommended approach: Start with SaaS, plan to build custom once you've validated your model.
---
Use Case #3: You Need Something Highly Specialized
Scenario:
- Compliance software with constant regulatory updates
- MLS integration (requires certification and ongoing maintenance)
- Payment processing with PCI compliance
Why SaaS wins:
- Providers handle regulatory changes
- Liability is on them, not you
- Complex integrations already built
Recommended approach: Use SaaS for regulated/complex systems, build custom for everything else.
---
Use Case #4: You're Not Planning to Scale
Scenario:
- Lifestyle business (you're comfortable with current size)
- Planning to exit in 1-2 years
- No interest in optimizing processes
Why SaaS wins:
- Good enough is good enough
- Lower short-term cost
- Minimal commitment
Recommended approach: Stick with SaaS and focus on what you enjoy.
---
When Custom Software is the Smarter Investment
Now let's talk about when building custom software makes financial and strategic sense:
Scenario #1: You're Spending $500+/Month on SaaS
The math:
- $500/month SaaS = $6,000/year = $30,000 over 5 years
- Custom software: $8,000-15,000 one-time + $200/month maintenance = $20,000 over 5 years
You break even in Year 2-3, then save thousands every year after.
When to build custom:
- You've been in business 2+ years
- You know exactly what you need
- Your workflow is stable
- You plan to scale
---
Scenario #2: Your Workflow is Unique
The problem with SaaS:
- Built for the "average" real estate agent
- Forces you to adapt to THEIR workflow
- Key features you need are "on the roadmap" (i.e., never coming)
Example unique workflows:
- Luxury real estate with concierge services
- Investment property analysis and deal flow
- Team collaboration with complex territory rules
- Integration with custom lead sources
When to build custom:
- You've tried 3+ SaaS tools and none fit
- You're working around limitations constantly
- Your competitive advantage IS your unique process
---
Scenario #3: You're Scaling a Team
The SaaS scaling problem:
- Per-seat pricing gets expensive fast
- 5 agents: $400/month → 20 agents: $1,600/month
- Features locked behind "enterprise" tiers
Example:
- Follow Up Boss: $69/user/month
- 10 agents = $690/month = $8,280/year
- 20 agents = $1,380/month = $16,560/year
Custom software:
- One-time build: $15,000
- Supports unlimited users
- Maintenance: $300/month = $3,600/year
At 10+ agents, custom is dramatically cheaper.
---
Scenario #4: Data Ownership and Privacy Matter
SaaS reality:
- Your data lives on their servers
- Subject to their terms of service
- They can shut you down, change pricing, or disappear
- Data export is often painful
Custom software:
- You own your data completely
- Hosted where you choose
- Control access and privacy
- Export/backup on your terms
When this matters:
- High-value client lists
- Proprietary processes
- Compliance requirements
- Long-term business asset
---
Scenario #5: You Want a Competitive Advantage
SaaS reality:
- Your competitors use the same tools
- Zero differentiation
- Everyone looks and operates the same
Custom software:
- Built around YOUR unique value proposition
- Features your competitors don't have
- Client-facing tools that impress
- Speed and efficiency others can't match
Example: A luxury broker built a custom client portal where high-net-worth buyers could:
- Filter properties by ultra-specific criteria (wine cellar, helipad, etc.)
- Schedule private showings via concierge
- Access market intelligence reports
- Communicate via encrypted messaging
Result: 34% increase in high-value leads, zero competitors could replicate the experience.
---
The Build vs. Buy Decision Framework
Use this framework to decide what's right for YOUR situation:
Step 1: Calculate Your Current SaaS Spend
List every tool you pay for monthly. Total it. Multiply by 12. Multiply by 5 (5-year cost).
If annual spend is under $3,000: SaaS is probably fine. If annual spend is $5,000+: Custom is worth evaluating. If annual spend is $10,000+: Custom likely makes financial sense.
---
Step 2: Assess Your Workflow Uniqueness
Rate from 1-5:
- 1 = Standard agent workflow, no unique processes
- 3 = Some customization, mostly standard
- 5 = Highly unique, competitive advantage built on process
If you're 1-2: SaaS is fine. If you're 3: Consider hybrid (SaaS for some, custom for core differentiators). If you're 4-5: Custom software is strategic investment.
---
Step 3: Evaluate Team Size and Growth Plans
Current team size:
- 1-2 people: SaaS
- 3-5 people: Either could work
- 6-10 people: Custom starts making sense
- 10+ people: Custom is likely better financially
Growth trajectory:
- Stable/declining: SaaS
- Slow growth: Either
- Rapid growth (2x in next 2 years): Custom
---
Step 4: Assess Technical Capability
Do you have (or can you hire):
- Someone to manage hosting?
- Basic technical troubleshooting skills?
- Ability to coordinate with developers for updates?
If no: SaaS is safer. If yes: Custom is viable.
---
Step 5: Calculate Break-Even Point
Formula: ``` Break-even = (Custom build cost + maintenance) / (Annual SaaS cost - Annual custom maintenance) ```
Example:
- Custom build: $12,000
- Custom maintenance: $3,600/year
- SaaS cost: $10,000/year
``` Break-even = ($12,000 + $3,600) / ($10,000 - $3,600) Break-even = $15,600 / $6,400 Break-even = 2.4 years ```
If break-even is under 3 years, custom makes financial sense.
---
Decision Matrix
| Criteria | SaaS | Custom | |----------|------|--------| | Annual spend < $3K | ✅ | ❌ | | Annual spend > $10K | ❌ | ✅ | | Solo agent | ✅ | ❌ | | Team of 10+ | ❌ | ✅ | | Standard workflow | ✅ | ❌ | | Unique competitive process | ❌ | ✅ | | Testing/experimenting | ✅ | ❌ | | Stable, proven model | ❌ | ✅ | | No technical knowledge | ✅ | ❌ | | Technical capability | Either | ✅ |
---
What Custom Software Actually Costs
Let's demystify pricing. Here's what you can expect:
Complexity Levels and Pricing
Level 1: Simple Internal Tool
- Examples: Custom lead tracker, contact manager, simple dashboard
- Scope: 2-3 core features, basic UI, no complex integrations
- Timeline: 2-4 weeks
- Cost: $3,000-8,000
---
Level 2: Moderate Business Application
- Examples: CRM replacement, transaction management system, team collaboration tool
- Scope: 5-8 features, polished UI, 2-3 integrations (email, calendar)
- Timeline: 6-10 weeks
- Cost: $10,000-25,000
---
Level 3: Advanced Platform
- Examples: Client-facing portal, AI-powered lead system, custom IDX solution
- Scope: 10+ features, mobile apps, complex integrations, AI components
- Timeline: 3-6 months
- Cost: $30,000-75,000
---
Level 4: Enterprise Solution
- Examples: Full brokerage management suite, multi-tenant platform, marketplace
- Scope: Dozens of features, white-label capability, extensive integrations
- Timeline: 6-12 months
- Cost: $100,000+
---
Ongoing Costs
Hosting:
- Small tool: $20-50/month (Heroku, DigitalOcean)
- Medium app: $100-300/month (AWS, Google Cloud)
- Large platform: $500-2,000/month
Maintenance and Support:
- Bug fixes and minor updates: $200-500/month (retainer)
- Major feature additions: Project-based pricing
Total ongoing: $300-1,000/month depending on complexity
---
Cost Comparison: 5-Year View
SaaS Stack (10-person team):
- Year 1-5 subscriptions: $60,000-90,000
- Hidden costs (labor, workarounds): $30,000-50,000
- Total: $90,000-140,000
- What you own at the end: Nothing
Custom Software (equivalent functionality):
- Build cost: $20,000-40,000
- 5 years maintenance: $18,000-60,000
- Total: $38,000-100,000
- What you own at the end: A valuable business asset
Net savings: $50,000-40,000 over 5 years
---
Real-World Case Studies
Case Study 1: Mid-Size Brokerage (12 Agents)
The problem:
- Paying $1,200/month for CRM, transaction management, email marketing, website
- Tools didn't integrate well
- Workflow required manual data entry
- Losing deals due to slow response time
The solution:
- Built custom platform combining CRM, transaction management, and automated follow-ups
- Cost: $28,000 build + $400/month maintenance
Results after 18 months:
- Saved $16,800 on software costs ($1,200/mo - $400/mo = $800/mo × 21 months)
- Eliminated 12 hours/week of manual work (valued at $31,200/year)
- 18% increase in conversion rate due to faster response times
- 5 additional closings attributed to improved workflow (approximately $50,000 additional revenue)
ROI: 294% in first 18 months
---
Case Study 2: Luxury Real Estate Team (4 Agents)
The problem:
- High-net-worth clients expected premium, personalized experience
- SaaS tools looked generic and cheap
- Needed custom branding and white-glove features
The solution:
- Built custom client portal with:
- Branded experience matching their luxury positioning - AI-powered property matching - Concierge scheduling - Encrypted communication - Market intelligence reports
- Cost: $45,000 build + $600/month maintenance
Results after 12 months:
- Client feedback: "Most impressive tech we've seen from any broker"
- 31% increase in referrals from existing clients
- Closed 8 deals directly attributed to differentiated tech (approximately $200,000 in commissions)
- ROI: 311% in first year
---
Case Study 3: Investment Property Specialist
The problem:
- Investors needed detailed ROI analysis and deal comparison
- SaaS tools didn't support custom calculations
- Spending 2 hours per property manually building spreadsheets
The solution:
- Built custom investment property analyzer:
- Automatic ROI, cash flow, cap rate calculations - Market data integration - Deal comparison tool - Investor client portal
- Cost: $18,000 build + $250/month maintenance
Results after 24 months:
- Saved 8 hours/week on analysis (valued at $20,800/year)
- Analyzed 3x more deals (increased pipeline)
- Closed 12 additional deals over 2 years (approximately $120,000 additional commissions)
- ROI: 423% over 2 years
---
Case Study 4: Team That Built Too Early (Cautionary Tale)
The mistake:
- Solo agent, first year in business
- Spent $15,000 building custom CRM
- Workflow changed dramatically as business evolved
- Tool became outdated within 6 months
The lesson:
- Custom software works best when workflow is proven and stable
- Start with SaaS when you're still figuring things out
- Build custom once you know exactly what you need
What they should have done:
- Used SaaS for 1-2 years
- Documented pain points
- Built custom once workflow stabilized
---
Common Myths About Custom Development
Myth #1: "It's Too Expensive"
Reality: Custom is more expensive UPFRONT but cheaper long-term. Break-even is typically 2-3 years for most real estate teams.
Example:
- Custom: $20K now + $5K/year maintenance = $40K over 5 years
- SaaS: $12K/year = $60K over 5 years
- Net savings: $20K
---
Myth #2: "It Takes Too Long to Build"
Reality: Most real estate tools take 6-12 weeks, not months or years.
Realistic timelines:
- Simple tool: 2-4 weeks
- Moderate complexity: 6-10 weeks
- Advanced platform: 3-6 months
Yes, SaaS is instant. But if you're planning to be in business for years, a few months of development is negligible.
---
Myth #3: "I'll Need a Full-Time Developer"
Reality: Most custom software requires minimal ongoing maintenance.
Typical maintenance needs:
- Bug fixes: 1-2 hours/month
- Small updates: 5-10 hours/quarter
- Major features: Project-based (as needed)
Solution: Retainer with development firm ($200-500/month) or project-based as needed.
---
Myth #4: "What If the Developer Disappears?"
Reality: This is a legitimate concern with poor planning. Here's how to protect yourself:
Require in contract:
- Source code ownership (you own all code)
- Documentation (how to run, deploy, and maintain)
- Code repository access (GitHub, GitLab with full access)
With these protections, any developer can take over your project.
---
Myth #5: "Custom Software is Harder to Use"
Reality: Properly designed custom software is EASIER because it's built for YOUR exact workflow, not a generic one.
SaaS: "Here are 100 features. Figure out which 10 you need." Custom: "Here are the 10 features you asked for, designed exactly how you work."
---
Myth #6: "I Can Just Use No-Code Tools"
Reality: No-code tools (Bubble, Webflow, Airtable) are great for prototypes but have limitations:
- Performance issues at scale
- Vendor lock-in (worse than SaaS)
- Limited customization
- Monthly fees forever
No-code is useful for:
- Testing ideas quickly
- Building internal tools
- Prototyping before full build
Custom code is better for:
- Client-facing applications
- High-performance needs
- Long-term business assets
---
How to Get Custom Software Built (Without Getting Burned)
If you've decided custom is right, here's how to do it properly:
Step 1: Document Your Requirements Thoroughly
Before contacting any developer, write down:
What you're building:
- Core purpose (e.g., "Replace our CRM and add AI lead scoring")
- Key features (list top 10)
- Who will use it (team, clients, both)
- Success criteria (what does "done" look like?)
Your current workflow:
- How do you currently handle leads?
- What data needs to be tracked?
- What reports do you need?
- What integrations are essential?
What you're replacing:
- Current tools and costs
- What you like about them
- What frustrates you
- What features you're missing
Pro tip: Record yourself walking through your current process. This video is gold for developers.
---
Step 2: Choose the Right Development Partner
Options:
Freelancer (Upwork, Toptal):
- Pros: Affordable, flexible
- Cons: Availability, quality varies wildly, communication challenges, no accountability if they disappear
Offshore Agency:
- Pros: Lowest cost
- Cons: Time zone issues, quality control, language barriers, hard to manage
Local Development Agency (like us):
- Pros: Accountability, clear communication, easier collaboration, legal recourse
- Cons: Higher cost (but you get what you pay for)
Our recommendation for real estate professionals: Work with a U.S.-based agency that specializes in business applications. The higher upfront cost pays for itself in quality, communication, and reliability.
---
Step 3: Evaluate Potential Partners
Ask these questions:
- "Show me similar projects you've built."
- If they can't show relevant work, walk away.
- "Who will actually write the code?"
- Some agencies outsource. You want to know who's doing the work.
- "What happens if you go out of business?"
- Ensure code ownership and repository access.
- "What's included in the price?"
- Design? Testing? Deployment? Hosting setup? Training?
- "What's your maintenance and support model?"
- Retainer? Project-based? Response times?
- "Can I speak with a past client?"
- If they won't provide references, red flag.
---
Step 4: Plan the Project Properly
Project structure:
Phase 1: Discovery (1-2 weeks)
- Developer interviews you about workflow
- Creates detailed requirements document
- Produces wireframes/mockups
- Agrees on timeline and milestones
Phase 2: Development (4-10 weeks depending on scope)
- Weekly check-ins and demos
- Iterative feedback and adjustments
- Testing throughout
Phase 3: Launch (1 week)
- Final testing
- Data migration (if applicable)
- Team training
- Go-live support
Phase 4: Warranty Period (30 days)
- Bug fixes included
- Minor adjustments
- Performance monitoring
---
Step 5: Protect Yourself Contractually
Must-haves in your contract:
- Clear scope of work (feature list, deliverables)
- Timeline with milestones (and payment tied to milestones)
- Source code ownership (you own all code)
- Documentation requirements
- Warranty period (typically 30-90 days for bug fixes)
- Confidentiality/NDA (protect your business ideas)
Payment structure:
- Good: 25% upfront, 25% at halfway point, 25% at launch, 25% after 30-day warranty
- Bad: 100% upfront (never do this)
---
Step 6: Manage the Project Actively
Your responsibilities:
- Respond to questions quickly (delays cost time and money)
- Provide feedback on demos (be specific, not vague)
- Test features as they're built (don't wait until the end)
- Prepare data for migration (clean your existing data before launch)
Developer responsibilities:
- Weekly updates (progress, blockers, next steps)
- Demo working features (show, don't just tell)
- Document everything (code comments, user guides, admin instructions)
---
Step 7: Launch Strategically
Don't just flip the switch:
Week 1: Soft launch with 1-2 team members
- Identify obvious issues
- Refine workflows
- Build confidence
Week 2-3: Roll out to full team
- Train everyone
- Monitor usage
- Address questions
Week 4+: Full production use
- Monitor performance
- Gather feedback
- Plan future enhancements
---
Taking Action: Your Next Steps
You now have the framework to decide between custom software and SaaS. Here's what to do next:
If You're Leaning Toward Custom:
Step 1: Calculate your break-even point
- Total your current SaaS spend
- Get quotes for custom build
- Run the math
Step 2: Document your requirements
- Write down what you need
- Record your workflow
- List pain points with current tools
Step 3: Get quotes from 2-3 development partners
- Compare pricing, timelines, and approach
- Ask for similar project examples
- Check references
Step 4: Make the decision
- If break-even is under 3 years AND you have proven workflow → build custom
- If you're still experimenting or solo → stick with SaaS for now
---
If You're Staying with SaaS:
Optimize your current stack:
- Audit what you're actually using
- Cancel tools you haven't used in 30 days - Consolidate where possible
- Negotiate pricing
- Annual plans save 15-20% - Ask about discounts for bundling
- Invest in integration
- Use Zapier or Make to connect tools - Reduce manual data entry
- Set a decision date
- When you hit $X/month in spend, revisit custom - When team reaches X size, revisit custom
---
Want Expert Help?
Schedule a free consultation and we'll:
- Review your current SaaS stack and costs
- Analyze whether custom makes sense for your situation
- Provide rough estimates for custom builds
- Recommend the best path forward (even if it's sticking with SaaS)
Or request a custom software proposal if you're ready to explore building exactly what you need.
---
Conclusion: Make the Right Choice for YOUR Business
There's no one-size-fits-all answer to custom vs. SaaS. It depends on:
- Your budget and runway
- Team size and growth trajectory
- Workflow uniqueness
- Technical capability
- Long-term vision
For most real estate professionals:
- Start with SaaS while you're figuring out your business model
- Switch to custom once you hit $500+/month in software spend, have a proven workflow, and are scaling a team
Custom software is not "someday" technology. It's accessible, affordable, and financially smart for established real estate teams.
The question isn't "Can I afford custom software?"
The real question is: "Can I afford to keep paying monthly fees forever for tools that don't quite fit?"
Run the numbers. Make the decision. Build what you need.
---
Ready to Stop Overpaying for SaaS?
Option 1: DIY audit your software spend and do the math yourself (start today)
Option 2: Get a free software stack audit and learn exactly what custom would cost for your business
Option 3: Request a custom software proposal if you're ready to own your tools
Whatever you choose, you'll be making an informed decision based on real numbers—not vendor marketing.
---
Related Resources:
- How to Build an AI Chatbot for Real Estate in 2025
- AI Automation for Loan Officers: Save 15+ Hours Per Week
- Real Estate Landing Pages That Convert: 10 Examples
- Chrome Extensions for Realtors: 7 Tools You Can Build Today
🤖 Generated with Claude Code
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>